Hey folks - as a member of the DawgNation community, please remember to abide by simple rules of civil engagement with other members:
- Please no inappropriate usernames (remember that there may be youngsters in the room)
- Personal attacks on other community members are unacceptable, practice the good manners your mama taught you when engaging with fellow Dawg fans
- Use common sense and respect personal differences in the community: sexual and other inappropriate language or imagery, political rants and belittling the opinions of others will get your posts deleted and result in warnings and/ or banning from the forum
- 3/17/19 UPDATE -- We've updated the permissions for our "Football" and "Commit to the G" recruiting message boards. We aim to be the best free board out there and that has not changed. We do now ask that all of you good people register as a member of our forum in order to see the sugar that is falling from our skies, so to speak.
- Please no inappropriate usernames (remember that there may be youngsters in the room)
- Personal attacks on other community members are unacceptable, practice the good manners your mama taught you when engaging with fellow Dawg fans
- Use common sense and respect personal differences in the community: sexual and other inappropriate language or imagery, political rants and belittling the opinions of others will get your posts deleted and result in warnings and/ or banning from the forum
- 3/17/19 UPDATE -- We've updated the permissions for our "Football" and "Commit to the G" recruiting message boards. We aim to be the best free board out there and that has not changed. We do now ask that all of you good people register as a member of our forum in order to see the sugar that is falling from our skies, so to speak.
SEC Power Rankings: Georgia, Alabama enter CFP ‘better’ vs. ‘deserving’ conversation
System
Posts: 11,452 admin
SEC Power Rankings: Georgia, Alabama enter CFP ‘better’ vs. ‘deserving’ conversation
ATHENS — It’s about time for the College Football Playoff Committee to start sorting out teams via its rankings, the first of which will be due out on Oct. 31.
Comments
Why is it a sign of nerves when Alabama asks their fans to show out? Kirby asks for this at every home game and then thanks the fans in the post-game interview. I get this is a UGA site, but that's some weird picking and choosing.
Sounds more like Saban trying to get some of Smart's tricks. Kirby mainly does it to have fans show up and not placeholders. I haven't been to a game in years, but the last one I went to, 2 ladies were sitting in front of me talking about all the shopping and stuff they were gonna do after, DURING the game. If you're not coming to the game to actually cheer or support your team, sell your ticket or give it to someone who actually wants to be there.
"If Lane Kiffin’s Rebels win out they would likely be a CFP team, even if they don’t play in the SEC Championship Game." The only way MS has any chance of making the CFP this season would be winning the SEC. There is a better chance of no SEC team making the CFP than MS making it w/o winning the SEC. Should TN beat AL on 10/21 and TN beat UGA on 11/18 THEN AL beat TN convincingly in the SECCG you could easily have no SEC in the CFP.
You could be right. I have only one proviso. We All know that media has Huge sway on who gets in the CFP. In particular ESPN.
Much of media, and Very Much ESPN, want Michigan ( Desmond & MI fans) and/or OSU ( Herbstreit and OSU fans) or possibly even Both in there to Knock Off whichever SEC team. Their starving for it !! Their sick to death of the chants SEC !! SEC !! SEC !!
So even though they by and large dislike the SEC they’d somehow find a way to put a UGA or Bama or Ole Miss in there. They are starving to prove that they can beat the SEC Champion !!
And even though Non-SEC fans would Never admit it publicly, a CFP without the SEC being represented would be very stale viewing on TV. Ratings would drop terribly, and as we know those ratings = millions of $$$ !! But I Do see your point and would fully agree if not for the proviso.
Like Most things in our country there’s Allot of politics involved that the Media has a very heavy hand in manipulating. Just for one example look how media have promoted Deion and Colorado, generating millions of $$$ for that school.
You are right that some things, outside of actual on field play, come into play when selections are made for the 4 team CFP field. The only way MS can win the SECw is for them to win out and for AL to lose 2 of their remaining 4 SEC games. Odds are not good for AL to lose 2 more games. So MS does not play in SECCG. Based on the rankings and talent of the top teams in the PAC12, BIG10 and BIG12 , MS is out.
Last year BIG10 had 2 teams in. You may see a "worst case" of MI/OSU/PSU with 1 loss each. BIG10 champ and 1 loss BIG10 team trump 1 loss, non SECCG participant MS. Add in BIG12 champ and runner up w/possibly 1 loss both ahead of MS. AND PAC12 champ (and possible 1 loss runner up) ahead of MS. THAT's before we add in the SEC champ and FSU (ACC champ). Just too many teams ahead of a non-SECCG participant. Same for UGA should it not make the SECCG. Too many teams that can be conference champs and undefeated.
Should TN beat AL tomorrow AND win the SECe then lose to AL in the SECCG you could easily see 4 non-SEC teams ranked higher than any SEC team. It is the last year of the 4 team playoff. There is no obligation to include any conference in the last 4 team playoff.
Based on last years CFBCG (most of the nation turned the game off after the 1stQ) an argument could be made that a CFP w/o an SEC team MIGHT draw more viewer interest. Since 2000 the championship has been won by an SEC team 14 times. The SEC could easily be passed over this year should AL win the SEC w/2 losses.
Don't fret, Navy. UGA won't come close to losing another game. Kirby's gonna unleash the Kraken on Florida. It's gonna be balls-to-the-wall to the Natty, from that point, on. You won't recognize em. Lol
IMO...Kirby & Company, used the first half of the season (15 games/7 used) to fertilize and cultivate every facet of the "team"...both, direct and indirect. He wasn't able to keep the Genie in the bottle very long, in '21 or '22. Clemson & Oregon forced his hand, in game 1, of both years.
If not for Oklahoma having to drop off the schedule...it would've been virtually the same scenario, this year. That allowed Kirby to do, pretty much, what he wanted to, without sacrificing a win. He tossed the fans a little red meat, every now and again. But, for the most part.. the last 7 games were glorified scrimmages.
This year...nobody's pushing them to play past 2nd or 3rd gear. I think Kirby has already put 90% of next year's roster together. Next year's team, will back up, this year's team...with a ton of experience under their belt. This strategy also allowed most of the 1's to stay fresh, for the meat of the season and CFP.
Can't wait for Jax! Go Dawgs.
This Is indeed a very weird year !! Allot to try to wrap our heads around. Let’s just hope our Dawgs can win hands down. I think they Can and I’m Believing they Will !!
One thing that seems to have by and large gone out the window is the “weak schedule” narrative promoted by media in preseason. KY was ranked when the Dawgs played them. At the moment the rest of the Dawgs schedule are all ranked with exception of GT. I don’t think the talking heads saw that one coming.
Losing Bowers was a big blow to the Dawgs, but there is still Tons of talent on this team. I’m confident that Kirby and staff are pushing them Hard during this Bye. Go Dawgs !!
Ah my optimistic Brother !! It’s infectious !! We all know that losing Brock did hurt. I mean he’s a phenomenal one of a kind player. But there is Still Tons of talent on this team. Tons !!
And I Believe that Kirby and staff are pushing them super hard during this Bye time. These Dawgs Know what’s at stake. I would really like to see better play from our Defensive front. I think they Will step up at least some. But we have great LBs to do just that Back Them Up !!
The Secondary is Really coming together. Dawgs Offense Will put significant amount of points, just to much talent not to. Just need the Defense to suppress the rivals score. Scoring Defense is the Most important of all.
People throw out all sorts of stats. But scoring defense is the most important and looking at the season, the defense is not as bad as some think in that lens. I Love that Release The Kraken comment !!! 😂 Let him loose on the Mud Lizards !! Go Dawgs !!
Because Saban RARELY does that. Kirby, on the other hand, has always had that kind of relationship with the fans - remember his first request that there be 90,000+ in his first G-Day game? He has always appreciated the fan's effect on the game. Saban has rarely felt the need to get the fans involved. That is why this is so unusual and shows a need for "extra" in order for the Tide to pull this one out. Tenn beat Alabama last year and poses a similar threat this year. Simple as that - Saban wants to avoid a losing streak against the Big Orange, something that would further cement the perception that he is less than what he was as a coach.
""If Lane Kiffin’s Rebels win out they would likely be a CFP team, even if they don’t play in the SEC Championship Game." The only way MS has any chance of making the CFP this season would be winning the SEC. There is a better chance of no SEC team making the CFP than MS making it w/o winning the SEC. Should TN beat AL on 10/21 and TN beat UGA on 11/18 THEN AL beat TN convincingly in the SECCG you could easily have no SEC in the CFP." - UGADad20
Who is MS?? I suspect you are talking about Ole Miss?
Lol...I thought the same thing. I think you're 100% correct. This year just feels "different" in Tuscaloosa...and, College Station, for that matter.
For the record...I see Mizzou as the most dangerous team in the SEC East this year....other than UGA of course.
And, I'm glad UGA already played Carolina and Auburn. Those two teams will be dangerous to whomever they play in the 2nd half of the season. They have improved every week.
So has GT. They could be a challenge to pretty much every team they play, going forward...with the likes of QB Haines King, Brett Seither and Dom Blaylock on offense and a much improved [over previous years] defense.
This is gonna be a fun Nov-Dec period of CFB. I'm looking forward to chaos....with exception of the Dawgs. They are the ONLY stable team I can find on the game-board.
I don't think it's as conspiratorial as all that, @navydawg. There are biases to be sure, and generally a lean toward the B10. But in most endeavors most people try to do the right thing, and I suspect that's true of most CFB voters.
Some voters may relish leaving the SEC out, because they'd like to see the mighty fall or just are biased. Others will give the benefit to the SEC because it's consistently proven to be the best conference. There's always controversy on who's picked, but usually they get it pretty close to correct, IMO. For example, last year they let Ohio State in over anyone in Pac-10 or ACC, or a two-loss Bama; Ohio State then proved they were right by almost beating Georgia).
Right now it looks like a one-loss SEC champion would have a hard time getting in. Oklahoma, FSU and Washington are favored to win out. If that happens, all three would outrank any one-loss SEC champ, even Georgia.
And even if all the Big10 big three lost one game to each other, the one-loss B10 champ most likely would take precedence over a one-loss SEC champion, because their best win and best loss would be better than the SEC's champ's.
Under the conditions described above, I think that would be fair. But of course it's college football!
FSU, Oklahoma and/or Washington could lose to much lesser team, or get beaten in their championship game. And, of course, I'm betting our Dogs will win out -- rendering all our tea-leaf reading irrelevant. Go Dawgs!
Voters base their vote on what they see on ESPN and OPO [Other People's Opinions]. If those opinions and networks have an agenda...it's reflected by most of the uninformed or misinformed or disinformation "voters".
It's politics. That's why I think...once the 12 team playoff is in effect, some of these perennial Champions will fade away, cause they'll have to "win it on the field", instead of the voting booth.
I agree with all of that with one exception. I think a 1 loss Georgia trumps any other 1 loss team because of the last two years. The three-peat potential would be irresistible.
Olé Miss and LSU in Tier 1
A+M and Florida I’m Tier 2
😬